Eat & Think: "Do I have to buy a wedding gift off of the registry?"
Emily Farris offers brutally honest advice on life, love and food
Monday, April 26, 2010
Dear Emily,
After college most of my friends went into finance, law and medicine while I decided to pursue more creative endeavors. Needless to say, most of them have a helluva lot more money than I do. I don't get to go out with them too often since they go to pretty swanky places I can't really afford, but we've managed to keep the friendships going strong.
Now we're getting to that age where a lot of them are getting married. So far, I've gotten invitations to four weddings this spring and summer, including one I'm a groomsman in. They're all pretty big affairs and my tux and travel for the wedding I'm in is going to cost me hundreds of dollars. It may be pocket change for those guys, but it's a lot to me. To add insult to financial injury, they've all registered at pretty pricey places, and I don't want to get them something crappy and uninspired like dishtowels.
My question is, do I have to buy something expensive (or inexpensive and lame) off of the registry or are there more creative, and much cheaper, options?
Sincerely,
Frugal Friend
Dear Friend,
In my opinion, while wedding registries are nice and easy for the people doing the buying (if they have enough money), they're part of a somewhat antiquated tradition. When people got married right out of their parents' houses, or even college, they needed pots and pans, wine glasses, coffee makers and the like. But now that people are waiting until their late 20s, 30s and 40s to marry for the first time, they just don't need all that crap. I'm 27 and have a full kitchen. While I'd someday like my yellowed hand mixer to be replaced by the KitchenAid mixer, I don't look at marriage as a chance to get all of those housewares I need (except for that KitchenAid mixer, in red). And it's not. It's a celebration of the love of the two people deciding to spend their lives together, and I think it's okay to do something they're not expecting.
I joke that my presence at a wedding is present enough — especially if I'm traveling for the festivities — but it's still nice to get something.
You say you're a creative person; why not make a gift? Paint them a picture, make them a sculpture or write them a poem. Use your talents to save yourself a few dollars.
I, of course, am always a fan of food or drink gifts, whether it's a home-cooked meal where I turn my dining room into a restaurant for two, or a gift certificate to my friends' favorite restaurants.
Do you know someone who home brews? Partner up with that person to make a case of beer for the happy couple. If your brewer already has all of the equipment, additional supplies should cost you about $30, and then you can order personalized labels online. Or go to The Roasterie and have a specialized blend made for the couple.
It really is the thought that counts. Just make sure you execute that thought and put a big bow and sincere card on it. Your friends will remember your thoughtful gift a lot more than they'll remember who got them the 16-quart All Clad stock pot and who got them the 12-inch frying pan. Promise.
Love,
Emily
Have a question for Emily? Send it to emilyf@kcfreepress.com.






















Comments
br3ndsaurus (anonymous) says...
i'm engaged, in my mid-20's, and half of a pretty artsy couple. i can honestly say that my fiance and i have most of the 'basics' folks used to put in their registries. we've had a hard time finding a good way to register because we appreciate quirky thoughtful things, or honestly just a tad of cash so we can travel or save for a big purchase like a new couch (still haven't found a classy way to ask for cash)...
for example - http://www.modcloth.com/store/ModClot...
that is a cool clock! and under $15! and we'd love it! you could also go the gift card route to places the couple likes - $20 towards booze at Gomer's or towards a place like Best Buy or a furniture store or a travel website are small things that would very much be appreciated!
then again, we're having a backyard wedding with indian buffet for the main course and my dress was $40. more posh people might expect more, but if they are ungrateful then that's just tacky on their part!
April 26, 2010 at 10:18 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
efarris (inactive user) says...
Registering on Etsy would be a great idea, too.
April 26, 2010 at 10:40 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
efarris (inactive user) says...
And, br3ndsarus, you might tell people you're "registered" with SmartyPig.com. It's an online savings account where other people can contribute towards your goal — whether it's a house, a couch or a honeymoon — which you can make public.
April 26, 2010 at 11:12 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
Bespecklednfreckled (anonymous) says...
We got a wide variety of gifts for our wedding, including, an original print, some wickedly awesome bourbon, a cupcake carrier...all things that our friends knew we would love. Gift registries are fine for picking a gift from, but I truly think that is original ideas that get remembered!
April 26, 2010 at 11:17 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
Rachelm (anonymous) says...
br3ndsaurus Another idea that my fiancé and I are considering is a honeymoon registry. We both love to dive and travel, so for a lot of our friends and relatives, that is the more thoughtful gift. Once again, I'm 30 and he's 28, so we have dishes, towels, etc, and while we will register for some of that, since some people aren't comfortable giving monetary gifts, we would rather have a memory together than a set of flatware together. You might try www.honeyfund.com. It's free and easy. Congrats!
April 26, 2010 at 11:37 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
flyingember (anonymous) says...
I got married roughly a year and a half ago.
We registered a couple places and still found plenty to register for. Sure, marrying when older you have stuff but some of it is likely worn out or weird sets.
It wasn't even a small deal if someone bought off the registry but we ended up with that we're glad we have.
That said a couple registering out of their guest's price range is a different story. We registering at Target and got every price range possible. It worked out great.
April 26, 2010 at 12:34 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
bullevard (anonymous) says...
I don't know if it just slipped by everyone or not, but I would have been pissed to unwrap a poem when we were opening wedding presents. My wife would have been too.
If you're going to go off registry then get cash or something consumable. We usually buy a collection of wines. The homebrew idea is a good one but only for a couple who really likes beer. If they're out of town, you can give the gift of KC BBQ or something like that from the KC stores in town. Then everytime they use that they can think of you.
I don't know, I'm not that thoughtful. I mostly just wanted to say don't give anyone a poem unless you're trying to have sex with them.
April 26, 2010 at 2:16 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
toodarnloud (anonymous) says...
Unless they register at a local boutique, nothing is better or more personal than cash.
And Emily, I got that big red mixer as a wedding present, but it wasn't even on our registry!
April 27, 2010 at 5:14 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )